Saturday, July 1, 2017

orthography - When did it become correct to add an “s” to a singular possessive already ending in “‑s”?




According to my grammar book, but at variance to the answer to this question, the correct singular possessive if a word ends in ‑s is:




James’s car




The grammar book allows exceptions for historical nouns, so the examples in the answer to the above-linked question would pass muster.



However, I’m sure that I learnt at school (which, admittedly, was a while ago) that for a singular (proper) noun ending in ‑s, the apostrophe went after the s and there was no additional s.




I don’t wish to start a flame war on which is correct, though my question doesn't really make sense if my grammar book is wrong! What I’m curious about is when the change occurred. :



So my question is when did James’s become the correct form and James’ the incorrect one?


Answer



Since, 1810, forms like James’s (which I will call type A) have generally been more commonly used than forms like James’ (type B), according to my research using the Corpus of Historical American English (COHA).



I compared a number of names ending in -s looking for possessive forms with and without a final s. Here is a graph comparing incidences of type A and type B forms:



graph showing forms with and without apostrophe since 1810.

The y-axis shows the difference in incidence between types A and B. If it is above 0, that means that type A was more common in that period; if below 0, that means type B was more common. The raw data used to generate the chart is in this Google Spreadsheet.



Here’s the same data, shown cumulatively:same data, shown cumulatively



For the 14 names tested, type A has been more common throughout the period beginning in 1810, except for the decades starting in 1850, 1940, and 1950.



Overall, it is quite clear that type A forms (e.g. James’s) predominate, and have done so for nearly two hundred years. Nevertheless, type B forms are also quite common, and during the 1930s to the 1960s, a number of names had more incidences using type B. But since 1970, most names have had a majority of usage in type A. As for the original question’s example of James, throughout almost the entire period, excluding 1820, incidences of James’s has strongly outnumbered incidences of James’.


No comments:

Post a Comment