Sunday, September 25, 2016

grammaticality - For as long "as" ... ? When is the last as not used? What are the rules?



For instance:





For as long as it takes...




but




For as long we have a future...





I know how to use them because I heard them being used, but I don't know whether there is a rule or not.


Answer



I don't know where you heard the second one, but it is incorrect. For as long as (or just as long as) is the only correct choice from your examples:




For as long as it takes...



For as long as we have a future...





As long as (see def. 37) is an idiom which has the following three meanngs:




a. provided that: As long as you can come by six, I'll be here.
b. seeing that; since: As long as you're going to the grocery anyway, buy me a pint of ice cream.
c. Also, so long as. during the time that; through the period that: As long as we were neighbors, they never invited us inside their house.




I'm assuming definition c for the two examples, but definition a also fits the second example. If that is the definition intended, then the for should be removed:




As long as we have a future...




No comments:

Post a Comment