Tuesday, February 25, 2014

where - When and if to use "What are you at now?"?



I wonder if "What are you at now?" is correct grammatically to use, in this format and context.



Two concerns that I have:




Ending with "at"




  • I am not ending the question with the "at". However, I am not sure adding a "now" at the end does help or not. Will this still be a valid question to ask? Is it valid to end a question with "at"?



Context




  • I am using it to address a person's need to understand where they are standing with a problem. The closest that I could think of to ask was "Where are you now?". However, I think the "Where" question is more about the location and not the state of the person.




I know there is a very similar question asked at here. However, mine is different in a sense that there is now at the end.


Answer



ODO actually gives a relevant example, though it labels the usage informal:




be at informal



Be doing or trying to do.




‘what are you at there?’




But the definition is different, addressing an activity rather than a state. This is not used the same way as 'Where are you at now?' Compare the contrast between 'What are you doing now?' and 'How are you doing now?'


No comments:

Post a Comment