Thursday, June 15, 2017

usage - "Yes, Please" vs "Yes, Of course"

I have heard people saying:



Que: Can I use your pen?



Ans: Yes please.




and also



Que: Can I use your pen?



Ans: Yes Of course.



I wanted to know if there is any difference between these two replies(may be of context) or can they be used interchangeably?



Thanks.

Wednesday, June 14, 2017

word choice - What colour eyes

I've just stumbled on this sentence What colour eyes does she have? in my grammar book. What got me interested in this is the combination of the words colour, eyes with what and without any prepositions.



I just assume a construction like this is possible with some particular words such as colour, form, shape, size and so on. These words have ranges or multiple possibilities.



Let me try this out.





What size sofa did you buy?




Since I think it's similar to what kind of car do you have construction, I don't have to use an article before sofa or do I?




What shape pancakes does the shop sell?





Are these 2 correct / possible? They make sense?



Any thoughts on this? Am I even right or it's just an insane theory? haha



UPDATE: Ok I can conclude people have different takes on this. So I want to ask you guys a couple of more things that will help me to understand this point better



1) If I always use "of" in such cases, will it always be correct?



2) What do we do with an article if we have a singular noun? optional or needed? From what I gather if we have "of" we need or opt for an article. If we don't we have to drop it. Is it like this? These below are just examples but I'm asking about a general idea for this kind of sentences
What size (a) sofa did you buy?
What shape of (a) pancake did she buy?

grammar - "New York is a great place to live." (no preposition?)




New York is a great place to live.



New York is a great place to live in.





I've seen the former usage a lot and I've started wondering what the grammar aspects of it are.



The main question I'm asking involves the grammar when the preposition in the end of the sentence is deleted. Is it equally formal or correct to omit it? What are the grammar properties of this?



Some more examples of similar usage:




This organisation is a great place to work.




This is a great place to stay/sit/study/travel/go.




Just to show that 'live' isn't special in this case.



Note: I'd posted the same question on ELL before, but the answers were not satisfying enough (the answers there did not seem to provide the precise grammar aspects of this, those that could be in a serious grammar book), so I'm posting this here to get some more views on the question. I hope it is acceptable.


Answer



Simply put: without the preposition, the infinitive is either a truly intransitive verb, or a truly transitive one; with the preposition, it is what is sometimes called a prepositional verb, i.e., a verb that—similar to how phrasal verbs work—must be paired with a preposition to take an object. The object is then not a direct object, but it is still semantically (and to a certain extent also syntactically) the object of the verb.





1A. I need a pen to write with.
1B. I need a pen to write.
2A. I have a book to write in.
2B. I have a book to write.




The difference here is clear: in the A sentences, it's explicitly stated that the pen is the instrument with which you will be writing and the book is the place you'll be writing. In 1B, a pen is just given as something that you need to have in order to carry out the act of writing; other things in that category would be paper, a desk, a chair, etc. (or these days, a laptop). In 2B, the book is simply the object of the verb.



In other words, when there is no preposition, you have to look at the constituents in the sentence to determine whether the verb is transitive or intransitive—if it's intransitive, the infinitive is often an infinitive of purpose (meaning in order to). When there is a preposition, you can usually assume the topic mentioned before the infinitive is part of a prepositional object, that is, the verb is acting in a mostly-transitive way, and the entire prepositional phrase is the object.



So what, then, of your example?





New York is a great place to live (in).




This doesn't seem to fit either: live in this sense does not take direct objects, and yet a place has no preposition.



This is because place isn't really and truly acting as a normal noun—it's more like the nominal form of the adverbial entity (some)where/here/there. Live in the sense we’re looking at here takes an adverbial phrase complement (like somewhere), but an adverbial phrase cannot be qualified by an adjective (well, it can; but its meaning changes a bit then), so a generic noun is substituted, acting as a stand-in.



If you replace place with a more regular noun that doesn't have this property, you'll see that they don't work:





*It's a great city to live.
*It’s a great street to live.




None of these two work, because you cannot *live a city/street the way you can live a place: a place is basically a noun phrase that has been semi-frozen as a pseudo-adverbial, acting like (some)where, so it takes no preposition. Cities and streets, though, do not do this, and they need to be part of a prepositional clause to be used adverbially like this. What does work is using an adverbial:




It's somewhere to live, I guess.




Naturally, if you use live as a transitive verb with a direct object, it works fine:





You only have one life to live!




And since place is still also a noun and can easily function as such, you can also use the prepositional verb live in [noun phrase] with it as the noun—which is why the double forms with and without the preposition are possible in your example.


grammar - What is the plural form of 'apocalypse'?



It was asked facetiously on the TV show Buffy the Vampire Slayer years ago, but surprisingly I have been unable to find a definitive answer on any of the common reference sites (such as Dictionary.com), though that did inform me the word is of Greek origin, then was migrated into late Latin and further into Middle English.



Apocalypsi?



Apocalypses?



Apocalypsis?




How would the plural form be properly pronounced?


Answer



Merriam-Webster's Eleventh Collegiate Dictionary (2003) suggests that the original apocalypse wasn't conceived of as a one-time-only armageddon:




apocalypse n [ME revelation, Revelation, fr. AF apocalipse, fr. LL apocalypsis, fr. Gr apokalypsis, fr. apokalyptein to uncover, fr. apo- + kalyptein to cover — more at HELL] (13c) 1 a : one of the Jewish and Christian writings of 200 B.C. to A.D. 150 marked by pseudonymity, symbolic imagery, and the expectation of an imminent cosmic cataclysm in which God destroys the ruling powers of evil and raise the righteous to life in messianic kingdom b cap : REVELATION 3 ["cap : an apocalyptic writing addressed to early Christians of Asia Minor and included as a book in the New Testament — called also Apocalypse"] 2 a : something viewed as a prophetic revelation b : ARMAGEDDON ["1 a : the site or time of a final or conclusive battle between the forces of good and evil b : the battle taking place at Armageddon 2 : a usu. vast decisive conflict or confrontation"] 3 : a great disaster {an environmental apocalypse}




While definitions 1b and (for the most part) 2b refer to Apocalypse as a one-off event, definitions 1a, 2a, and 3 do not. Perhaps most interesting, definition 1a suggests that someone living 2,000 years ago could make a career—or at least an avocation—of writing apocalypses.




The prospect of multiple apocalypses in the definition 3 sense is bolstered by the history of film over the past fifty years, wherein the possibility (if not probability) of countless zombie apocalypses—especially in Hollywood—has become an industry trope.



As for the plural form, it is simply apocalypses, just as the plural of eclipse (which has a different etymology) is eclipses.


ambiguity - Ambiguous pronouns

I have a statement like




The performance of the proposed scheme, and its dependence on …




Here, ‘it’ can refer to either the performance of the scheme, or the scheme itself. I changed the statement to





The performance of the proposed scheme, and the dependence of the performance on …




– which doesn’t seem very professional due to redundancy.



It is possible to change the statement in such a manner that it is unambiguous as well as sounds professional (for an academic document)?



For the sake of completeness, the full sentence is





The performance of the proposed scheme, and its dependence on various parameters, including X and Y, is reported.




EDIT:



I was able to use the ideas from some answers here to come up with a sentence that I'm pretty satisfied with:




The proposed scheme's performance and its dependence on various parameters, including X and Y, is reported.





However, now I don't know which answer to accept, since this solution came to me after reading multiple solutions here! Please help?

Tuesday, June 13, 2017

What is "depth grammar"?



I remember learning about it (ha) in linguistics class at uni, but then I went to the pub.



I remember the idea was interesting. It had something to do with the undiscovered rules of language that we must know intuitively and/or subconsciously in order to learn language in the first place.


Answer



Are you talking about deep structure?


Sunday, June 11, 2017

grammaticality - Reported speech or no?

Why in the sentence like this:"John called and told me he is on his way.He should be here soon",-there is no the reported speech, and the verb"is"doesn't change from the present tense form into the past simple form "was" though the word "told" denotes speaking and stands in the past form?