Sunday, February 5, 2012

grammaticality - Because as a preposition



Recently, I have seen discussions that state that "because" is always a preposition. Can someone shed light on this idea? Thank you.



UPDATE:



The question that prompted me to post this question: Is "which" a preposition? Because because



I posted this question for several reasons:




1) I have seen this topic come up in comments before. I don't remember the original posts that led to the comments...perhaps another user can recall.



2) I could not follow all of the reasoning in the referenced article (Language log) and am hoping a user can bring the discussion "down to earth" for the rest of us mortals.



3) Language is not set in stone, and I have the feeling that other words will soon change use. I think it's important to see how people discuss the words that are changing and to understand these inevitable changes.



4) I think it would help us have a better understanding of ideas such as "preposition" and "Subordinate conjunction" and "conjunction."


Answer



Conventionally because is considered a conjunction, because it links (or conjoins) two clauses. The argument against its classification as a conjunction is that because operate like other subordinating or coordinating conjunctions but does operate like prepositions.




This post on the Language Log demonstrates that because is not a conjunction by comparing it to that (subordinating conjunction) and and (coordinating conjunction). I summarize the argument below.



Typical subordinating conjunction: that




  • That can be omitted from a sentence and the sentence's meaning generally remains the same.

  • The clauses cannot be rearranged and maintain meaning: "[clause 1] that [clause 2]" != "that [clause 2], [clause 1]".

  • Complements follow that.

  • If because is omitted from a sentence the meaning does not remain the same.


  • With because the clauses can be rearranged.

  • Adjuncts generally follow because.



Typical coordinating conjunction: and




  • The two clauses joined by and can be rearranged and the meaning stays the same.

  • And cannot start a sentence.

  • Rearranging the clauses changes the meaning with because.


  • Because can start a sentence.



Because does not act like conjunctions, and thus is not a conjunction. It does, however, act like prepositions.



Prepositions can introduce noun-phrases, clauses, preposition phrases, and nothing, depending on the preposition. Because has long introduced clauses and preposition phrases (with of) and more recently also introduces noun-phrases.


No comments:

Post a Comment