Monday, November 2, 2015

Comma use before "as"?



I'm writing an essay and I was wondering if I would put a comma here before as:




Reputation is based on integrity and wisdom as your ability to demonstrate probity would gain you favor among many people.



Answer



As adds nothing here. Get rid of it and use two separate sentences:




Reputation is based on integrity and wisdom. Your ability to demonstrate probity would gain you favor among many people.


verb agreement - "There (are/were/is/was) no pus or polyps." Which is correct?

Someome asked me which of these sentences is correct:





There are no pus or polyps.




Or




There were no pus or polyps.





Honestly, both sound wrong to me. I'd say, there was neither pus nor polyps.



I figure it's a compound subject, so you should use a plural verb (were). However, I'm not sure.



I know there are a lot of similar answers, but they weren't that helpful.



So, could someone please explain if were or are is correct? Or should the entire sentence be changed?

phonology - Why do photons and protons exhibit such anomalous behavior?



I first noticed in this answer that there is something sneaky going on with the word photon: its ‹t› is the stressed allophone of /t/, a fully aspirated [tʰ]. It does not reduce to [t] or [ɾ] the way it does in words like voting. Other words with the same issue include proton and lepton.




The only way I can explain this would be if the second syllable in such words bears secondary stress, so [ˈfoʊˌtʰɑn].



Even so, the question remains: why does this happen? Is it because these are all “new” words? Or does Greek somehow enter into it?



I notice other new scientific terms have the related issue of an unreduced vowel in the syllable without primary stress, such as in hadron, quasar, protein, baryon, genome.



So the ‹t› in proton and photon works more like it does in Motown or cow town, but those are at morphemic boundaries. The only “old” word I could think of where it might work the same way (remain aspirated) might be in canton. But there the vowel in the unstressed syllable does seem a bit reduced, just not all the way.



What is really going on here?







Edit: The mid-word aspirated ‹t› also occurs in futon and wonton (as in wonton soup), but not in Briton, Milton, tartan, titan, wanton (as in a wanton woman).


Answer



As Bruce Hayes (UCLA) puts it,




Word-medial voiceless stops are aspirated provided they are in the onset of a stressed syllable and are not preceded by a strident (Hayes 1995: 13).





Thus,



proton [ˈpʰɹouˌtʰɑn] in AmE.



There's no secondary stress in "voting" in AmE.



See a note on aspiration in the Longman Pronunciation Dictionary (3rd ed., Wells 2008: 45) - those rules are rather comprehensive; at least, that should be enough for someone who's not a professional phonetician.



The most important thing to remember is that aspiration is not binary, aspirated or unaspirated, but rather gradual. See fig. 6.6 in Ladefoged 2006, A Course in English Phonetics.



Acronym of abbreviation for "At the time of writing this document"?



I'm wondering if there is some special abbreviation for "At the time of writing this document".
I am writing a document that contains names of individuals to contact in certain scenarios, and it is labeled with its date of creation.



I want to be explicit though about who should be contacted, but remind some potential reader this may have changed if said contact leaves the company or is replaced. Or if there is some kind of global fallout.




Proposal if this doesn't exist: ATTOW - At The Time Of Writing this document.


Answer



ATTOW At the Time of Writing FreeDictionary and AcronymFinder


Sunday, November 1, 2015

punctuation - Do I need an apostrophe in "These trees’ roots"?




Do I need an apostrophe in "These trees’ roots"?



For example,



"Wow!!! These trees' roots are so long!"



In this example the speaker can see both roots and the trees themselves.


Answer



Yes, you need the apostrophe. -s' denotes possession of some thing or things by multiple owners. The roots belong to the trees; the trees own the roots. Therefore, the roots are the trees' roots.



hyphenation - Hyphenating measurements




A construction that I have been seeing a lot lately that seems surprising to me is "The 8-foot-long bridge ...," with two hyphens.



It seems surprising to me (or maybe I'm just noticing it) that there is a second hyphen between "feet" and "long".




Is this considered a common construction or is it more of an accepted though less common use?


Answer



In the United States, most style guides that I have encountered recommend including the second hyphen in situations such as "8-foot-long bridge." Here is how some guides frame their advice. From The Associated Press Stylebook (2002):




dimensions Use figures and spell out inches, feet, yards, etc., to indicate depth, height, length, and width. Hyphenate adjectival forms before nouns.



[Relevant examples:] the 5-foot-6-inch man, the 9-by-12 rug





From The New York Times Manual of Style and Usage (1999):




long(-), (-)long ... As a suffix, long forms a solid compound when it attaches to a one-syllable word ending in a consonant. The compound is hyphenated if the suffix directly follows a vowel or a word of more than one syllable: daylong, decade-long, hourlong, minute-long, mile-long, monthlong, second-long, weeklong, yearlong. Do not attach -long to a plural: instead of weekslong delay, write a delay of weeks.



Shorten expressions like two-hour-long meeting. Two-hour meeting says it all.




From The Chicago Manual of Style, fifteenth edition (2003):





7.90 Overview. ... number, spelled out, + noun: a hundred-meter race, a 250-page book, a fifty-year project, a three-inch-high statuette, it's three inches high, five- to ten-minute intervals. (Hyphenated before a noun, otherwise open. Note the space after the first number in the last example.)




From Bryan Garner, Garner's Modern American Usage (2003):




PHRASAL ADJECTIVES. A. General Rule. When a phrase functions as an adjective preceding the noun it modifies—an increasingly frequent phenomenon in 2oth- and 21st-century English—the phrase should ordinarily be hyphenated. Hence, the soup is burning hot becomes the burning-hot soup; the child is six years old becomes the six-year-old child. Most professional writers know this; most nonprofessionals don't.




...



PUNCTUATION. ... J. Hyphen [-]. ... Here's the rule: if two or more consecutive words make sense only when understood together as an adjective modifying a noun that follows, those words (excluding the noun) should be hyphenated.




Since we're talking about punctuation style here, there is no single objectively correct way to handle the hyphenation of compound adjectives; but as a matter of convention, the style guideline that yields "8-foot-long bridge" is considerably more firmly established in U.S. publishing than the one that yields " 8-foot long bridge."


grammar - A weird case : "The kitchen’s window" vs "The kitchen window"



I just came across this article (noun modifiers), and I'm surprised that these two nouns mean different things:




The kitchen’s window



The kitchen window





The Ngram shows zero usage of the first one even though it's very common .



Ngram



Here are some articles using the first one ( The kitchen’s window ):



The New York Times Making a New House Look Old





The kitchen’s window and door combination has an arch similar to that
of the brick-in arch elsewhere in the facade.




One biotech gasps for breath




[...] and an assortment of sweets soon cover a long table by the
kitchen's window .





How come?
Thanks.



Update :



Thanks to @Lawrence, I've noticed that there is an Ngram apostrophe issue, and that's why it shows zero usage of kitchen's window . To workaround this issue, I used a wildcard and here is the result of the kitchen * window
( Please, click on search lots of books to see the result ):




enter image description here


Answer



First off, in the source sentence:




The kitchen’s window and door combination has an arch similar to that
of the brick-in arch elsewhere in the facade.




The possessive "kitchen's" does not modify "window", but rather "window and door combination". If one did use "kitchen" in this context the reader might well be led down the garden path to concluding that the reference was to a door/window combo similar to that that might be used in a kitchen (even though, in this case you could be talking about a bedroom).




And in the second source sentence:




[...] and an assortment of sweets soon cover a long table by the
kitchen's window .




What's being described is the layout of the kitchen. Thus a specific window is being referred to, and window is not so much a feature of the kitchen but rather a "landmark".




As with most things English, the rules are mushy, but the non-possessive use of "kitchen" to modify "window" implies a window of the type used in a kitchen, while the possessive implies a window which is "owned" by the kitchen.



There is plenty of room for both forms to be used, depending on context.