Saturday, January 26, 2013

"With whom" vs. "with who"




It suddenly came to my mind that this is quite strange:






  1. Obama, with whom I was at school, has just come to live in our street.

  2. Who are you hanging out with?




Obviously, both sentences are correct, so is "with whom".



But... why do you say "who are you hanging out with", not "whom"?


Answer




You can certainly ask Whom are you hanging out with?— it's completely grammatical— though the kind of person who would say it would probably use the even more stilted With whom are you hanging out?



The difference between who and whom has been covered extensively in previous questions. Whom has been suffering a steady decline (in conversational English) for some decades, and sounds formal or affected. As such, you'd be unlikely to hear it used with the colloquial hanging out, as whom is largely absent from less formal registers these days. Additionally, it is familiar to see who at the head of a sentence as an interrogative pronoun, so it is either less noticed by or less objectionable to pedants.


No comments:

Post a Comment