Wednesday, January 7, 2015

relative clauses - What part of speech is "the closest" in this case?


What is the closest you've ever come to losing your life?




(From : https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-closest-youve-ever-come-to-losing-your-life



Apparently, it comes from the construction "come close to doing" , so "the closest" should be an adverb (in superlative degree) . But relative clauses cannot modify an adverb.(I follow the CGEL by Quirk et al.)



Someone would view it as a NP where the noun has been omitted(the closest situation). But this analysis is also flawed, because a NP cannot fit in the relative clause that follows.




Is there a better idea ?

No comments:

Post a Comment