Saturday, March 30, 2013

Punctuation of reported speech within direct speech

I've got a fiction 'speech within speech' situation, and I'd like opinions on how to handle the internal final punctuation -- inside or outside the quotes. This is British English.




Example: The character says:



[Statement A]



"Oh no, he always brings that up, ‘Just like the last time, it’ll be,’ he says, never lets me touch a drop."



Problem: in British English that comma after "be" would go outside the final single quote mark if it wasn't direct speech, ie., if an omniscient narrator says:



[Statement B]




John was liable to say "Just like last time, it'll be", or something like that, which annoyed her.



So, in the first example, A, does my character qualify as a surrogate omniscient narrator? In which case the comma should go outside the single quote? Or does the interior quote qualify as a reporting direct speech, in which case the comma stands as I've rendered it, inside the single quote?

No comments:

Post a Comment