Monday, April 4, 2016

conditionals - "was" as a past subjunctive

I'd like to know whether "was" should be treated as a subjunctive in the following:




a. If there were a 20-story office building without an elevator, those whose office was on the 18th floor would climb many steps each day.




b. If there were someone who was able to speak over 500 languages at native levels, he would be considered a genius of some sort.




Here was is used to describe hypothetical situations and is considered correct even in Standard American English



I'd appreciate your help

punctuation - Separating dependent clauses and introductory phrases with commas in compound and complex-compound sentences



I know that you are supposed to separate dependent clauses and introductory phrases with a comma if they start the sentence. Examples:





  1. If you are ill, you ought to see a doctor. (dependent clause)


  2. After the adjustment for inflation, real wages have decreased while corporate profits have grown. (introductory phrase)




Reference: https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/



However, the above reference does not give examples of punctuating compound and complex-compound sentences that include dependent clauses and introductory phrases in the second part of the sentence.



Example of such a sentence with original punctuation kept (I took it from Wiktionary — an example of usage for word particular in sixth definition):





He is very particular about his food and if it isn't cooked to
perfection he will send it back.




I think that there should be a comma after the word food, but that is not my question.



My question is if there should be a comma after the word perfection.



Similarly, sould there be a comma after an introductory phrase which comes after the first indepedent clause but before the second indepedent clause? (Although it is probably considered to be a part of that second independent clause.)




[independent clause], + coordinating conjunction + [introductiory phrase] + [independent clause].



Comma or no comma after an introductory phrase in the above structure?


Answer



Punctuation is a matter of style, and as such you should be governed by your manual of style, either the one you've chosen or the one thrust upon you. I prefer The Chicago Manual of Style, but whichever one you choose realize that the there will always be allowance for the author's necessarily subjective judgment.



CMS notes that when it comes to punctuation, form follows function, and that said function has three components: to clarify meaning, to aid the reader, and to contribute to style. There are two schools of thought -- close punctuation (which supplies the marks to follow the syntax as much as possible) an open punctuation (which supplies the marks only in those cases of possible "misreading.")



Close style will always recommend and open style will usually concur that coordinated independent clauses be separated by a comma unless the the clauses are very short:





George washed and Martha dried.




In the given example, a middle-of-the-road style will thus recommend that the sentence have a comma preceding and and following the dependent clause:




He is very particular about his food, and if it isn't cooked to
perfection, he will send it back.





Close style will bracket the dependent clause with commas:




He is very particular about his food, and, if it isn't cooked to
perfection, he will send it back.




This looks choppy, and even in 1982 when the 13th edition of the CMS was recopyrighted, this style is noted as somewhat out of favor.




A strong open style will omit the commas in the second clause or even omit all the commas on the grounds that a markless sentence won't lead readers into misparsings.


Sunday, April 3, 2016

abbreviation for september and october in the 18c. English manuscripts

While I am reading a 18th c. manuscript, months of september and october are abbreviated as "7ber". I have not come across any other abbreviation for differing them. Can you please help me, is “7ber” September or October?

What is the correct way to write multiple possessives, rather than the common way?

In the phrase, "Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Webber's Jesus Christ Superstar...," I believe Rice should end in 's, as Webber does, because the show is as much Rice's as it is his partner's. However, whenever I've seen multiple nouns in a possessive, the first noun does not have thhe 's. I cannot fine a grammar rule to address this. Is it a case in which people have written and said it wrong for so long, the incorrect use has become acceptable? Which use is correct?

writing style - Is this use of en dash legitimate?

In the following sentence, how do you understand the en dash?





Our findings are very interesting from an international viewpoint – business tourism.




Is the use of the en dash appropriate here?



Spoiler



By using an en dash, the author of this sentence said he wanted to give just a hint or a summary of what the findings were without having to write too much.

personal pronouns - Is the sentence "we are playing with my friend" correct if the "we" only means my friend and me?

My friend says it should be "My friend and I are playing", but I think "We are playing with my friend" is correct too. Is it?

grammaticality - Using "An" and "A" in a sentence




I'm trying to understand this simple concept.



As far as I understood it, back to the days when I was a student, "an" should be used only before vowel words, that is, only before the following words: "a","i","o","u".




Yesterday my sister asked me a question related to this subject and I wasn't sure if my answer was correct because there are so much controversial sources explaining this subject.



The original question she asked me was which one of the following is the correct form to be used in a sentence:




An history




Or





A history




I told her that she should use "a history" only because 'h' isn't a vowel word. Is it correct?



Thank you very much


Answer



Words of one or two syllables beginning with ‘h’ are normally preceded by ‘a’. They include ‘hotel’, ‘hostel’, ‘host’, ‘hearty’, ‘hero’ and ‘hardy’. (Some speakers may say ‘an hotel’, because ‘hotel’ is also a French word, in which the ‘h’ is not aspirated.)




Words of three or more syllables beginning with ‘h’ in which the first syllable is stressed are also preceded by ‘a’. They include ‘history’, ‘herbalist’, ‘heightening’ and ‘helicopter’.



Words of three or more syllables beginning with ‘h’ in which the second syllable is stressed give rise to some uncertainty. They include ‘historian’, ‘historical, ‘hiatus’ and ‘Hibernian’. I and some other speakers of British English precede them with ‘an’, but others don’t.