I've looked other places online to try and find the answer to this question and was unable to confirm if I should use an apostrophe for both words or not. It seems awkward to do so but grammar rules appear to tell me otherwise. The situation I'm thinking of is one like this: "Mary's sister's lasagna" or "Joe's dog's bone." From the rules I've read I'm pretty sure that both words would need an apostrophe because they are both possessive, and each in their own right possessing individual things: it's Mary's sister, and the sister's lasagna. If it were Mary and her sister's lasagna, the apostrophe could go after 'sister' because they both are sharing possession of the same thing.
Sunday, May 4, 2014
Saturday, May 3, 2014
grammatical number - Having a singular subject and a plural object - which form to choose for the verb?
Possible Duplicates:
In special cases, can you use “one such family are” vs. “one such family is”?
[Singular] Is/Are [Plural]?
I often encounter sentences like
The best solution is / are implicit parameters.
Which form is correct in this case?
grammar - Use of "on" when talking about scores
Why does English use the preposition on when giving a score as in Joe is on 10 points rather than Joe has 10 points?
Friday, May 2, 2014
Indefinite article before "format"
I need to use this word with the following meaning:
the way in which data is stored or held to be worked on by a computer
This particular dictionary doesn't say anything about whether this word is countable or not. The given example though contains an indefinite article:
The images are stored in a digital format within the database.
So, it is supposed to be a countable noun. But when I reviewed some other examples I've discovered that putting an indefinite article along with the noun is not always the case:
However, neither the raw nor the processed data were provided in digital format.
No data were reported in digital format.
Could you please clarify the cases for me?
Thursday, May 1, 2014
gender neutral pronoun - he/she or it
I'm a bit lost in gender neutrality. Please see the example below.
A: What, I got a child‽
B: Sooner or later *he or she* will show up.
From my own research, people put preferences this way: they > she > she or he > he. I think that they, she and he should not be used as it is only one child and we do not know anything about the gender. So she/he does seem to be the most suitable for this sentence. Or is it not?
PS: Would you rather write "he/she" or "he or she"? (I find she before he less natural than vice versa, although people on the internet say...)
Answer
We could really do with a gender neutral singular personal pronoun ("it" never seems appropriate as a personal pronoun) but sadly we simply don't have one. There's no single correct answer for how to deal with this, as much of it is embroiled in personal preferences. Common approaches include:
- Using "he or she" or "she or he" throughout. In writing this is often shortened to "he/she", "s/he" or "(s)he".
- Choosing one of "he" or "she" (more or less at random) and sticking to it - possibly alternating between them if using lots of different examples. Sometimes this approach is accompanied by an explanatory footnote
- Using "they" instead of a singular pronoun. Looking up the definition of "they", "used to refer to a person of unspecified sex" is certainly one of the options listed; it is not incorrect to use "they" to refer to a single individual.
My personal preference is the latter, as it strikes me as less cumbersome and retains consistency between the written and spoken word. In my experience this seems to be becoming the more popular approach, although I haven't conducted any research on the matter. As I said earlier though, there is no single objectively correct or most preferable approach.
Edit: The Urban Dictionary lists "thon" as a gender neutral singular personal pronoun but the more conventional dictionaries I looked at don't list that definition, and it has yet to become established in common usage.
pronouns - When to use “that” and when to use “which”?
When is it appropriate to use that as opposed to which?
Answer
That and which are interchangeable when introducing integrated relative clauses. Although some grammar mavens (i.e., people who hold forth on such topics but know little or nothing about linguistics) and copy editors will insist otherwise, the rule is completely bogus.
See, for instance, Language Log on that vs which, written by the co-editor of The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.
Practically speaking, it is not something that any normal person will generally notice or follow in spoken English and it's frequently — and rightly — ignored even in literary writing. So even from that point of view it's not worth worrying about.
grammar - Why do not we ask negative questions without a contraction on the not after the verb?
I have found multiple questions touching on this but not a single one that has a comprehensive answer. The information is all there but in little bits.
Exactly why is "Do not you sleep?" ungrammatical (except in poetry/with artistic license)? I understand that not can't contract after you: "Do you not sleep?" because not can only contract after a verb, and that it always does after do: "Don't you sleep?" but why does it (why must it) contract if it's placed after the verb in a question?
- Don't you sleep? (common form)
- Do not you sleep? (ungrammatical)
- Do you not sleep? (less common form)