Monday, September 3, 2012

grammaticality - When is it correct to use the "-wise" suffix?



I found myself writing the following in a bit of technical documentation:




The Trainers' and Students' clients have very little in common, both user interface-wise and code-wise.





At first, I wondered whether I should have written user-interface-wise, user interface-wise, user interface wise or user interfacewise... or some other combination. A quick Google search suggested however that the "-wise" suffix actually isn't one you can or should use on any word.



What do you suggest? I guess the easiest way out is rephrasing (e.g., not only for what concerns the user interface, but also for actual methods), but I wanted to learn whether appending "-wise" to arbitrary words is incorrect, frowned upon or merely a stylistic choice.


Answer



TheFreeDictionary.com gives this usage note:




Usage Note: The suffix -wise has a
long history of use to mean "in the
manner or direction of," as in

clockwise, otherwise, and slantwise.
Since the 1930s, however, the suffix
has been widely used in the vaguer
sense of "with respect to," as in This
has not been a good year saleswise.
Taxwise, it is an unattractive
arrangement.
Since their introduction,
these usages have been associated with
informal prose, and they are still
considered by many to be awkward. For

this reason, they might best be
avoided, especially in formal writing.
The most obvious alternative is to use
paraphrases, as in This has not been a
good year with respect to sales. As
far as taxes are concerned, it is an
unattractive arrangement.




The meat of this suggests that using -wise to mean with respect to is considered informal and even awkward. I suspect that pushing the boundaries as you do in the examples to include such constructions as user interface-wise makes an awkward usage even more awkward, as your own instincts seem to suggest. I generally have no problem with informal speech or writing in informal settings or for emphasis, but whenever I feel I am pushing the envelope I'll pause, think, and probably recast the sentence.



Sunday, September 2, 2012

grammar - What is the function of "doing" in "when doing something"?



Can anyone please explain if "doing" in "When doing something" is a base+ing verbal, or a present participle used as a verb in an elliptical sentence, or something else entirely.
Here's an example of a sentence:




"When training, athletes build their endurance by practising their
sports for long, exhausting hours."





And if it indeed is a part of an elliptical sentence, why is that so, and how is that different from this:




"Last weekend, I saw lots of ducks splashing around in the pond."




I understand that in this sentence splashing is a base+ing verbal, functioning as a modifier in a noun phrase.


Answer



"When training, athletes build their endurance by practising their sports for long, exhausting hours."




I would say it is a present participle.



Training, athletes build their endurance...
This is one of usages for the participle. In your case, to clearly indicate the relationship between the participle "training" and the main sentence "athletes build...", "when" is added.



https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/627/02/
The usage is shown in this URL



http://www.ego4u.com/en/cram-up/grammar/participles/exercises?13
Some of them use a conjunction with a participle as your example uses "when"



What is the correct way to use infinitive after the verb "help": with or without "to"?



What is the correct way to use infinitive after the verb "help": with or without "to"?



For example:





Please, help me to understand this.




or:




Please, help me understand this.



Answer




The particle "to" is not wrong in this sentence, but it is unnecessary. I would recommend against using it.



The phrase "to understand" can be interpreted as a special case of the infinitive; a kind of future infinitive or impersonal future tense. In that context, the first sentence means, essentially, "please help me develop an understanding of this (in the future)". While that may be technically correct, it adds nothing to the meaning of the sentence.



To add some weight to my argument, the COCA lists 142 entries for "help me understand" versus only 18 for "help me to understand". The results are similar for other constructions involving "help me ..." versus "help me to ...".



I think that the confusion stems from the way you must use the infinitive in other cases, for example: "I want to understand this", or "I am trying to understand this". In these cases, the particle is an absolute neccesity.


grammaticality - Subject/object in this sentence: "Against no one was feeling more bitter than against Rhett Butler"



From Gone with the Wind, Chapter 16, by Margaret Mitchell, 1936:




Against no one was feeling more bitter than against Rhett Butler.





I understand what it means, but I don't understand how this sentence works grammatically. I am confused about what the subject and object of this sentence are.



To me, it seems like either the object or the subject is missing. Is the "one" in this case referring to Butler or to the people feeling bitter?



Is this just a rare type of grammatical construction, or is there something I'm missing?


Answer



It's easier to understand in context (emphasis and comments are mine):





It was a situation made to order for speculators and profiteers, and
men were not lacking to take advantage of it. As food and clothing
grew scarcer and prices rose higher and higher, the public outcry
against the speculators grew louder and more venomous.
In those early
days of 1864, no newspaper could be opened that did not carry scathing
editorials denouncing the speculators as vultures and bloodsucking
leeches and calling upon the government to put them down with a hard
hand. The government did its best, but the efforts came to nothing,
for the government was harried by many things.




Against no one was [this] feeling more bitter than against Rhett Butler. He
had sold his boats when blockading grew too hazardous, and he was now
openly engaged in food speculation.



Saturday, September 1, 2012

meaning - What are the nuances of the British expression "gone" used with time, as in "gone 8" or "gone midnight"?

An expression I have run across in British novels is "gone [hour]" like this:





"It was gone midnight, and the house was quiet." The Midnight Witch by Paula Brackston



"It's only just gone eight o'clock, Hugo, and Maria hasn't brought our
tea yet." Caribbean Sunset with a Yellow Parrot by Andrea
Frazer




I suspected from context that this means sometime past that hour, generally where I might say "after eight" or "past midnight", which is confirmed in this (closed) post. I appreciated the detail that it isn't used for planning purposes.




I am still wondering about some of the nuances of usage. This question has resisted my attempts at regular research, with most searches turning up pages of meanings for "gone" or "o'clock" but nothing much useful for the full idiom (except for the above-linked question here). I actually asked a cabbie about this when I was in England for a few days last year, but he wasn't sure. (It's surprisingly difficult to strike up conversations about English usage with random Londoners, at least for me.) I also haven't figured out a good way to express or look for the idiom generally, since there are at least fourteen common formulations (gone one, gone two, gone noon, etc.) and "gone" by itself is obviously not useful. So:




  1. Is there a limit on how long after the hour you could use "gone"? (I
    know this is not likely precise, I'm just wondering approximately
    how it would be understood by those who use the idiom.) For example,
    if it's 8:50 could you still say "gone eight"?
    (In comparison, I think I would probably only use "after eight" until 8:29; after
    that I would say "eight-thirty" or "after eight-thirty" or "almost

    nine" etc.)



    How much does the addition of "just" narrow down the window?



    Does this depend on hour in question? For example, in the first sentence
    above are we to infer that the time was sometime between midnight
    and 1am (or 12:30 or whatever the appropriate cut-off is), or is it
    less specific, meaning generally late at night?


  2. My guess is that this expression comes from something like "midnight
    had come and gone"--does anyone know any more about its origins than

    that?

  3. Are there any situations besides the hours of the day that this
    usage of gone would be appropriate? For example, "she's gone
    fourteen weeks pregnant" or "my baby is gone eleven weeks old" or "it was gone summer by the time the
    plantings were ready"?



Many thanks for any insight, and my apologies if this question is unduly fine-drawn. Obviously, I've been wondering about this a lot!

relative clauses - "that" omission, subject-verb distance

when can we remove 'that'? I've heard different opinions



I bought the book that is required for this course
I bought the book required for this course



I recommend that you take my advice
I recommend you take my advice




I know that you are correct
I know you are correct



the report that was approved by the board was written by Susan
the report approved by the board was written by Susan



We are studying advertisement strategies that other companies use to recruit minorities
We are studying advertisement strategies used by other companies to recruit minorities

noun-pronoun agreement


Like the planets, the stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous
speeds, but they...





Just based on the above, how can we tell which noun the pronoun they refers to: planets or stars? Is there any rule to determine which is which?



The sentence finishes like this:




...are so far away from earth that their apparent
positions in the sky do not change enough for their movement to be
observed during a single human existence





I know that 'intuitively' you can 100% say that they refers to stars. But, for example, if you replace planets with X and stars with Y, how can you decide what they refers to?