Monday, November 26, 2012

grammar - Is 'subject' in 'is subject to considerable debate' a verb or a noun?




Every once in a while I stumble upon this phrase:



... is subject to considerable debate


Examples are easily found on the web, for instance:



In the context of suspected cognitive disorders,
the validity of memory complaints is subject to considerable debate



However, this phrase does not seem grammatically correct to me. I could expect it to be:



... is a subject for considerable debate


in which case 'subject' is a noun, or:



... is subjected to considerable debate



where 'subject' is a verb in past participle.



Still, both alternatives are much less common, judging by the number of occurrences in Google, than the original phrase. So here are the questions:




  1. Is this phrase appropriate for formal writing?

  2. Is it appropriate for less formal conversation?

  3. Finally, is 'subject' in this phrase a noun or verb?


    1. Where should I put the stress when I read the phrase aloud?



Answer



Using the comments posted to the original question, I can assume the whole answer, which is:




  1. Yes, it is appropriate for formal writing.

  2. No, it probably won't fit in a casual informal conversation.

  3. 'subject' is an adjective, therefore its form is perfectly correct.


    1. The stress should be on the first syllable as ['sʌbʤekt].



No comments:

Post a Comment